The National Anti-Corruption Commission (NACC) is in dire need of a second chance to prove its worth and regain public trust. The recent budget estimates hearing, where outgoing NACC chief Paul Brereton faced scrutiny, highlighted the challenges the commission faces. Brereton's abrupt resignation, two years ahead of his term, and the ongoing investigations into his conduct have cast a shadow over the commission's integrity.
The NACC's struggles are multifaceted. The commission's handling of the robodebt royal commission referrals and Brereton's poor management of conflicts of interest have significantly damaged public confidence. The fact that Brereton recused himself from defence matters due to his involvement in the Afghanistan war crimes investigation, only to be later questioned by the attorney-general about his consulting commitments, raises questions about transparency and accountability.
The NACC's decision to reconsider the robodebt saga investigation, following a finding of apprehended bias, further underscores the commission's challenges. The initial refusal to investigate, despite the involvement of a former army reserve colleague, Kathryn Campbell, who was subject to adverse findings in the royal commission report, has led to 900 public complaints and a severe erosion of trust.
Brereton's testimony during the hearing revealed a culture of fear among NACC staff, who are terrified of making mistakes and facing findings of officer misconduct. This fear, he suggested, could lead to bullying when staff are called to give evidence by parliamentary committees. While the NACC has exposed corrupt conduct in various sectors, the commission's own internal issues have become a distraction, undermining its credibility.
The government's planned 'reset' under a new commissioner is a necessary step. However, the NACC requires a more comprehensive overhaul. The appointment of a commissioner with a better attitude towards parliamentary scrutiny and a focus on transparency and accountability is crucial. The commission must also address the balance between operational secrecy and public scrutiny, ensuring that the public's trust is not further eroded.
The NACC's future hinges on its ability to demonstrate authority and integrity. With a statutory review of its functions looming in 2027, the commission must act swiftly to address its shortcomings. The appointment of a new commissioner, coupled with increased transparency and accountability, is essential to restoring public confidence and ensuring the NACC's effectiveness in the fight against corruption.
